There was a flurry of discussion on #yalitchat last week about the indispensability (or not) of romance in YA. I think this was the match that sparked the tinder:
@cafecliche: Do you think YA without a central romance can sell?
I tuned in long enough to voice an opinion. (“Yes, emphatically and unequivocally yes. YA w/o a central romance can sell.”) Others opined and concurred:
I think the romance or no question is actually more interesting and complicated than it seems. Somebody smart (@jsgabel I think) pointed out farther down the # tag that an emotionally meaningful human relationship is indispensible in almost any fiction. Unsurprisingly, we find the romantic ones most interesting, and so they’re well represented in YA and elsewhere. But there are plenty of books where that central relationship is not “romantic,” so I think the answer to the initial query is “yes,” so if that’s all that concerns you, go back to what you were doing.
Still here? Cool. There will be rewards. I’m increasingly interested in the romantic arc of YAs where there is a central romance. Specifically, I’m concerned with the end of that ARC. Do YA romances tend unswervingly toward a marital apotheosis*, whether actual or implied? (Free book to the first three commenters with examples of recently pub’d YAs with teen nuptials strongly suggested.)
And does YA explore the question of romantic finality as thoroughly as it might, or is there interesting territory here yet unexplored?
Marriage is a powerful force in our storytelling traditions. A marriage is the formal ending of almost any Elizabethan comedy. There’s a wedding in the last episode of M*A*S*H* and the promise of one in the end of Sex and the City. Even Buffy has a wedding. And on and on.
And of course marriage is a huge issue in American culture in general (same-sex, Bristol and Levi, tax penalties, etc.).
So it’s no surprise it comes up in YA, but I’m wondering if there is unexplored territory here due to to the overwhelming pull of The Wedding on our stories (I’m looking at you, epilogue to Deathly Hallows). Central romances in any other type of storytelling (and any other phase of life) you can think of tend toward marriage if they’re successful. Shouldn’t YAs resist this? Do they? It seems to me like it’s really hard to do a significant, central romance that is explicitly not marriage bound (despite the fact that that’s the case for nearly all teenage relationships in real life). But the pay off for “really hard” is generally “really interesting” in my experience.
I think one of the trickiest things about YA is that it is fundamentally anti-ending, despite all the ceremony we associate with the end of high school. Think about it: what’s a bigger deal, the finality of getting your diploma or the unresolved status of all those friends and lovers? Nearly every American teen knows that the end of high school isn’t the end of anything specific other than their early-morning destination five days a week and nine months of the year. (And since a high school diploma won’t get you a decent job anymore, this is more true than ever.) Teenagers make their peace with uncertainty as they end adolescence, but they don’t resolve that uncertainty. This applies to relationships (what is a marriage if not a resolution of uncertainty?).
So, I want more reading material on marital subjects: First, comments and tips on YAs that address particularly well the awful nebulousness of high school romances at the end of high school. Second, I’ll take queries for existing manuscripts that address this theme. I’m interested in YAs with central romances that know they’re doomed (and not for extraordinary reasons—fatal illnesses, galactic cataclysm, etc.) and how they cope. Go here for how to send queries. The query offer is good until 11:59 PM on June 24, 2011.
*Free Carolrhoda book to anyone who can upack that reference.